Conditional use · Planning application
Reptile zoo approved for former axe-throwing building
The Garden City Planning and Zoning Commission approved a conditional use permit on Oct. 15 for an indoor reptile zoo in an existing 8,964-square-foot building. Conditions include closing two of three driveways on Chinden Boulevard and providing at least 18 vehicle and 18 bicycle parking spaces.

From the filing
The application's description as it appears in City of Garden City's record. See the official record
The applicant, Tyler Messina, requests a conditional use permit to operate a reptile zoo at 3725 W. Chinden Blvd. in Garden City, in an existing building previously used for axe throwing. The site is about 0.689 acres, and the applicant proposes no exterior changes, with the work focused on the interior and on street, sidewalk, landscaping, and parking improvements.
Tyler Messina is requesting a conditional use for Reptile Zoo, comparable to the GCC designated uses of Animal Care Facility/Commercial Entertainment Facility at 3725 W. Chinden Blvd, Ada County parcel #R2734511345, located in the C-1 Highway Commercial Zoning District
Timeline
Oct. 15, 2025
Approved
Garden City Planning and Zoning Commission: Approved.
Oct. 15, 2025
Public hearing: Garden City Planning and Zoning Commission
Aug. 20, 2025
Application filed
Documents
Site plans
- Download Overall site plan
Site plan for the Idaho Reptile Zoo in Garden City showing the existing building, parking area, and design criteria notes for a conditional use permit.
Sept. 9, 2025 · 1 page · 361 KB
Plans
- Download Revised site and landscape plans, parking details
Revised submittal for the reptile zoo conditional use permit listing parking counts and stall dimensions, a landscape plan for the west planter and north entry, property photos, and an owner permission affidavit.
Sept. 14, 2025 · 8 pages · 3.7 MB · Revised plans
Staff reports
- Download Staff report for conditional use permit hearing
Planning staff's recommendation of approval, with conditions, for a commercial entertainment use (reptile zoo) under the conditional use permit application, for the Oct. 15, 2025 hearing.
Yesterday · 27 pages · 1.7 MB · Staff Report
Decisions
- Download Planning and Zoning Commission decision on conditional use permit
Findings of fact, conclusions of law and decision by the Garden City Planning and Zoning Commission, treating a reptile zoo as comparable to animal care and commercial entertainment uses.
Oct. 14, 2025 · 15 pages · 328 KB · Decision
Notices
- Download Affidavit of property posting for conditional use permit hearing
Notarized affidavit certifying that the property was posted for public hearing notice on the Oct. 15, 2025 hearing, at least ten days before the hearing.
Yesterday · 3 pages · 7.6 MB · Notice
Application
- Download Conditional use permit application form
Applicant Idaho Reptile Zoo requests a conditional use permit for an indoor live animal exhibit in a Commercial Entertainment zone, with no structural changes.
Aug. 19, 2025 · 17 pages · 9.4 MB · Application packet
- Download Applicant response letter to Planning and Zoning Commission
Applicant's letter argues the conditional use permit is procedural for a reptile zoo, compares it to a prior axe-throwing use, and disputes staff's streetscape and landscaping recommendations.
Yesterday · 3 pages · 210 KB · Application packet
Correspondence
- Download Boise Fire Department comments
Fire Marshal's letter stating the fire district can approve the conditional use permit for a reptile zoo, subject to building and fire code compliance at permit stage.
Sept. 28, 2025 · 1 page · 129 KB · Agency comment
- Download City engineer review comments
Engineering review by Centurion Engineers for the city engineer, listing conditions on owner permission, ITD right-of-way approval, fire district review, irrigation and water/sewer.
Sept. 28, 2025 · 3 pages · 414 KB · Agency comment
- Download Ada County Highway District comments
ACHD states no adjacent street improvements are required, and lists traffic impact fee, driveway approach permit, and right-of-way permit requirements plus standard conditions.
Sept. 21, 2025 · 3 pages · 222 KB · Agency comment
- Download Idaho Transportation Department comments
ITD requires closing both curb cuts in front of the building, directs access to the parking lot approach or Stockton St., and requires an ITD permit for any work in right-of-way.
Sept. 18, 2025 · 1 page · 184 KB · Agency comment
- Download Idaho DEQ general agency comments
Department of Environmental Quality comments on air quality, fugitive dust, wastewater and sewer capacity rules that cities should consider for the project.
Sept. 14, 2025 · 4 pages · 742 KB · Agency comment
- Download Republic Services comments on conditional use and plat applications
Republic Services says it has no concerns with the reptile zoo conditional use permit if trash service stays the same, and no issues with the residential plat if it uses carts.
Sept. 11, 2025 · 2 pages · 263 KB · Agency comment
